Skip to main content

Soomaaliya/Breaking

OP-ED: From Strategic Partner to Political Enemy – Hassan Sheikh's Contradictory Position on the UAE

The United Arab Emirates (UAE) has arguably provided more financial and material support to Mogadishu and the Federal Government of Somalia than its investments in Somaliland and Puntland combined. According to estimates shared with Gaylan Media by credible sources, more than $1.2 billion has been channelled through different avenues in Mogadishu over the past several years, excluding UAE investments and assistance in Somaliland, Puntland and Jubaland.

Senior Desk·16 hours ago·3 daqiiqo akhrin389101
OP-ED: From Strategic Partner to Political Enemy – Hassan Sheikh's Contradictory Position on the UAE
Yet, there is a fundamental difference in how this support has materialised. While UAE assistance to the Federal Government has largely involved financial contributions, military support, humanitarian operations, institutional capacity-building and other forms of assistance, its investments in Somaliland and Puntland have been more tangible and visible. These include the development of Berbera Port in Somaliland, Bosaso Port in Puntland, and support for the fight against Daesh in the Cal Miskaad mountains. Such investments and engagements have been directed towards infrastructure, institutions and broader public interests rather than individuals or particular political groups. The UAE's support for Somalia is not a recent development. It goes back many years and has included military training, security-sector assistance, humanitarian relief, healthcare, development projects and support for Somali communities. President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud himself has, on several occasions, acknowledged the UAE as one of Somalia's friendliest partners in terms of investment, direct assistance and historical commercial relations. However, in his latest public address in Mogadishu, Hassan Sheikh adopted a markedly different position, accusing the UAE of interfering in Somalia's internal affairs and criticising its close relations with Somaliland, Puntland and Jubaland. Ironically, these three administrations are among the country's most relatively stable and secure regions, with no established Al-Shabaab presence in their principal administrative centres, and have demonstrated considerable progress in maintaining security and developing their institutions. Rather than acknowledging the contributions of partners who have supported these administrations, the President appeared to portray their external partnerships as a threat to Somalia's national interests. The question, therefore, is not whether Somalia has legitimate sovereignty concerns or whether foreign countries should respect its territorial integrity. Those are legitimate issues. The more important question is why a country that has contributed so substantially to Somalia's security, development and humanitarian needs is suddenly being portrayed as an enemy. UAE's support and the $1.2 billion support The UAE's assistance to Somalia over the past decade has been extensive, although not all of it is reflected in the Federal Government's annual budget accounts. Estimates provided to Gaylan Media by credible sources suggest that total assistance directed towards the Federal Government and communities in Mogadishu and southern and central Somalia exceeds $1 billion, with some estimates reaching $1.2 billion. These figures exclude investments and assistance directed towards Somaliland, Puntland and Jubaland. Some of this assistance is reflected in World Bank and Somali Ministry of Finance reports. However, a substantial portion has reportedly been channelled through arrangements that do not necessarily appear as direct budgetary transfers. These include military financing, soldiers' salaries, training, logistical support, humanitarian operations, hospitals and other development projects. The significance of this assistance was recently highlighted by Abdulkhaleq Abdalla, a UAE-based university professor, who wrote on X about the various forms of support Abu Dhabi has extended to Somalia. He specifically mentioned training soldiers of the Somali Federal Forces, strengthening their military capabilities, paying their salaries and providing general support to the Federal Government to enhance Somalia's security and stability. Abdalla's remarks also echoed earlier statements by former Somali President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed, who has openly discussed the UAE's support for his family. Abdalla's account specifically referred to the UAE covering the rent for the Hassan Sheikh’s family's residence. These statements have added another dimension to the debate about the nature and extent of Emirati support to Somali political leaders and institutions. The UAE's response and Somaliland's reaction The first senior UAE official to respond to President Hassan Sheikh's allegations was Dr Anwar Mohammed Gargash, Diplomatic Adviser to the UAE President. In a statement on X, Gargash stressed that the UAE had stood by Somalia and its people during their darkest hours. He added that the relationship between the two countries would remain deeper and stronger than fleeting political disputes, personal calculations and political ambitions. Somaliland also responded swiftly to the President's remarks. Khadar Hussein Abdi, Somaliland's Minister of the Presidency, defended the UAE's partnership with Somaliland, highlighting its investments in Berbera Port, roads, schools and other vital infrastructure. He expressed gratitude for what he described as a brotherly partnership and continued support, while arguing that Hassan Sheikh should concentrate on putting his own house in order rather than criticising Somaliland's international partnerships. These reactions illustrate how the UAE's relationship with Somalia has become entangled in the country's internal political divisions. However, they also raise a broader question about whether the Federal Government's current position reflects a consistent foreign policy or a political disagreement with administrations that maintain independent relationships with Abu Dhabi. Hassan Sheikh's previous statements contradict his current position Perhaps the most striking aspect of the current controversy is Hassan Sheikh's own record of statements about the UAE. On different occasions, both as an opposition figure and during his latest presidential term, he openly acknowledged the Emirates' contribution to Somalia. Some of his earlier remarks, which are available on YouTube and have since been widely circulated by his critics, describe the UAE as a major supporter of Somalia. He acknowledged its assistance in training Somali forces, strengthening the military, fighting terrorism, supporting investments and even assisting Somalia's diplomatic representation in the UAE. These were not statements made by an opposition politician unfamiliar with the country's affairs. Some were made while he was serving as President, with direct access to information about the nature and extent of the UAE's engagement with his administration. How, then, did a country previously described by the President himself as a major supporter of Somalia suddenly become an enemy accused of undermining the country's sovereignty? There is an ongoing narrative in Mogadishu portraying the UAE as a dangerous adversary whose intentions towards Somalia are fundamentally hostile. But can such sentiments be taken seriously without examining the history of bilateral relations and the substantial assistance Abu Dhabi has provided? Critical thinking requires more than accepting political accusations at face value. It requires examining the record, the interests involved and the consistency of those making the allegations. A similar political narrative has previously been directed against Ethiopia, which was often portrayed as Somalia's historic enemy. Yet, upon assuming the presidency, Hassan Sheikh emphasised the importance of peaceful coexistence, describing Ethiopians as brothers with whom Somalia should maintain good relations. If historical grievances with Ethiopia could be reconsidered in the interest of regional peace, why should Somalia's relationship with the UAE be reduced to hostility over political disagreements? Opposition leaders and regional administrations defend the UAE Hassan Sheikh's criticism has also been challenged by opposition figures and leaders of Federal Member States, some of whom have publicly acknowledged Abu Dhabi's contribution to Somalia. Former President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed, who recently visited his family in the UAE, was subjected to fierce criticism by social media trolls, with some portraying him as a political puppet serving Emirati interests. He has nevertheless remained unapologetic about his position, describing the Emirates as a brotherly country and questioning why visiting Dubai should become a political offence. His remarks have also drawn attention to the apparent double standards surrounding the issue, given that members of the current President's extended family have themselves enjoyed accommodation and hospitality in the UAE. Puntland's President has similarly acknowledged the UAE's contribution to the region's security, particularly its assistance in the campaign against Daesh in the Cal Miskaad mountains. He has indicated that the success of the operation would have been considerably more difficult without Emirati support. More recently, an event in Garowe also demonstrated public expressions of appreciation for the UAE's contribution. Meanwhile, Mohamed Adan Kofi, a former senior NISA official and spokesperson for an opposition group, dismissed the accusations directed at the UAE in a recent media interview. He questioned the credibility of Hassan Sheikh's changing position, arguing that the President's apparent double standards were difficult for the public to accept. Political disagreements should not erase historical contributions There is nothing inherently wrong with Somalia defending its sovereignty, questioning foreign interference or reviewing agreements that it considers contrary to its national interests. Every sovereign government has that responsibility. Equally, foreign partners should respect Somalia's constitutional order and its political institutions. However, diplomatic disagreements should not become an excuse to rewrite history or discredit years of assistance and cooperation. A country cannot reasonably acknowledge another state as a strategic partner when its support is politically convenient and subsequently portray it as an enemy when disagreements emerge. The UAE has maintained substantial relations with different Somali administrations, political leaders and communities. Its investments in Berbera and Bosaso, its security assistance in Puntland, and its financial, military and humanitarian contributions to Mogadishu are all part of that record. Ultimately, Hassan Sheikh's recent remarks raise a question of political consistency. If the UAE was a friendly and indispensable partner when its assistance benefited the Federal Government, what fundamentally changed to make it an enemy today? And if the President genuinely believes that the UAE has violated Somalia's sovereignty, why has he not presented a clear and consistent account of these alleged violations while acknowledging the country's previous contributions? Somalia needs a coherent foreign policy built around national interests, mutual respect and strategic partnerships, not one that changes according to political convenience. Its leaders should be able to defend national sovereignty without dismissing genuine contributions from international partners or turning diplomatic disagreements into campaigns of political hostility.
Wadaag: Twitter Facebook LinkedIn

Faallooyinka (0)

Soo gal si aad uga qaybqaadato wadahadalka.